Shelley Shepard Gray’s Top 10 Amish Destinations

September 18th, 2015

A Wedding at the Orange Blossom InnBeing a well-loved Amish fiction author, Shelley Shepard Gray has travelled to many Amish communities. She joins us today to share her top 10 Amish destinations and why you, too, should add these places to your travel list. Make sure to check out Shelley’s latest release, A Wedding at Orange Blossom Inn, and enter to win a copy today. Click here to learn more and enter. 

More about A Wedding at the Orange Blossom Inn:

Emma Keim was heartbroken when her husband, Sanford, passed away, leaving her to raise three young daughters alone. Though several years have passed, her relatives have made it no secret that they expect Emma to remain a widow, mourning Sanford indefinitely. But when she meets Jay Hilty—a handsome widower with three young sons of his own—Emma is delighted to have a new friend who understands her struggles. Still, she is dismayed that her family is so opposed to their friendship—and the idea of it ever becoming anything more. She honors her husband’s memory every day, but is she destined to be alone forever?

 1) Sugarcreek, Ohio.

famous clock at sugarcreek

I’ve written 7 books that take place in Sugarcreek. It’s also where my Amish friends live, so I’ve been here quite a bit. When I think of my very favorite Amish communities, this lovely, adorable town always comes to mind first.

2) Adams County, Ohio.

Adams County Covered bridge

This is the community that is just an hour away from where I live. It’s where I saw my first buggy. There’s also a lovely inn there, called The Murphin Ridge Inn, where my girlfriends and I have stayed at many times for writers weekends. There is also a covered bridge here, which is fun.

3) Keim Lumber

Keim Lumber

For next year’s series which will be set in Charm, I visited Keim Lumber. It’s huge and has just about everything anyone would want. It’s also just about the prettiest lumber retail store you could find!

4) Walnut Creek Cheese Shop.

Walnut Creek Cheese Shop

This is my very favorite place to shop in Amish country. It’s a massive place, which everything from fresh fruits and vegetables, homemade ice cream, books, jams, and gourmet cooking supplies. There is also a terrific mix of Amish, Mennonite, English and tourists inside.

5) Pinecraft, Florida.

I recently discovered Pinecraft and have now visited there two times in two years. It’s located in the heart of Sarasota. Amish from all over the country visit here in the winter. The best place to visit in Pinecraft (for me, at least) is Yoder’s Restaurant. Best. Pie. Ever.

6) Siesta Key, Florida.

Siesta Key FL

This is the beautiful beach just about a ten-minute drive from Pinecraft. It’s listed as one of the best beaches in America. It features silky white sand, few people, and warm water. What more could a person want, especially in February?

7) Shipshewana, Indiana.


About five years ago, I went on an Amish Country Tour with authors Vannetta Chapman and Amy Clipston. We got to ride in the Shipshewana Christmas Parade! Being the parade was a hoot. Seeing the beautiful area, all covered in snow and twinkling lights? Amazing.

8) Crittenden County, KY.

Blue Bridge in KY just outside Crittenden County

I wrote four books set in this southwestern county in Kentucky. The area is remote, a little bit wild, and the people couldn’t have been kinder or more helpful. The town in the heart of it is Marion. Very close is Paducah, which has a large quilt fair every year.

9) Berlin, OH.

If someone has never been to Amish country, I often tell them to visit Berlin. There are lots of shops and restaurants here. It’s a lot of fun. My favorite place to visit here is the Gospel Book Store. It’s in a building that also houses a grocery store and pharmacy. The Pioneer Trails buses pick up and drop off Amish here, too. So it’s fun to imagine going on a bus trip with them down to Florida for the winter!

10) Der Dutchman Restaurant in Walnut Creek.

As you might imagine, I’ve eaten at a lot of Amish restaurants! I have to admit that this is probably my favorite. They had a chicken pot pie that is phenomenal. Sitting in a booth at Dutch Valley brings back a lot of great memories.

[Tweet “Discover @shelleysgray’s 10 must-see #Amish spots on @litfuse’s blog”]

Are you new here? You might want to subscribe to our email updates, or follow us on FacebookTwitterPinterest, Google+, or Instagram.

Shelley Shepard Gray

{More About Shelley Shepard Gray}

Shelley Shepard Gray is a “New York Times” and “USA Today” bestselling author, a finalist for the American Christian Fiction Writers prestigious Carol Award, and a two-time HOLT Medallion winner. She lives in southern Ohio, where she writes full-time, bakes too much, and can often be found walking her dachshunds on her town’s bike trail.

Find out more about Shelley at


  • connie lynch says:

    Love Shelley’s works a lot

  • Barbara Prisinzano says:

    Shelley !! I’ve been reading your Books for about a year now !! I guess your a keeper now ! I love reading your Books !! U just wanted to say last year my sister went to Berlin to see you !! Well it turn out that I missed you be a week !! Boy was I sad to hear that !! But I did love Berlin !! I can’t wait to get started on your new Books. !! keep writing an I’ll keep reading !!